Inter-Asia Cultural Studies: Movements

 

回首页

About IACS

Current Issue

Back Issues

Visual essays

IACS Project

Events

Links

Archives

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  » Issue contents  2020-03-23 Some thoughts on the endgame of resistance
Some thoughts on the endgame of resistance: Ngo-yiu Naam-chaau as terminal reciprocity

Stephen C. K. CHAN
 
ABSTRACT 
The act naam-chaau (mutual destruction) can be taken as a move, a process, or a terminal strike registered at specific junctures in the intensifying situation of Hong Kong. In the course of the leaderless popular movement against government since June 2019, through media publicity, flash protests and overseas lobbying, the work of naam-chaau has given rise to higher-level damages, restrictions and concerns beyond police frontlines. The popular English phrase “If we burn, you burn with us!” is often adopted to annotate tactical actions which undermine the legitimacy of the state apparatus in question. During the “Be Water” resistance movement, physical and non-physical confrontations are mediated on multiplying levels or “front lines” of the resistance. Noting the continual evolvement of such tactics and with a focus on the widening significance of violence — not least that of the police- and system- violence — I reflect on the situated moves of naam-chaau as a terminal reciprocity. With a perspective on mutual destruction as a real possibility when the new Hong Kong normalcy comes to stay, we could look at this gaming tactic on three levels, culminating in what has been characterized as “the endgame.”
 
KEYWORDS: Resistance; violence; body politic; postcolonial Hong Kongers; burning together 

Notes on contributor

Professor of Cultural Studies at Lingnan University, Chan is published internationally on Hong Kong culture, cinema, literature, education and cultural studies. His research covers cultural politics and identity narratives; martial arts cinema; pedagogy, creativity and performance. Currently Chair of the Association for Cultural Studies, Chan was convener of the inaugural Steering Committee of the Consortium for Inter-Asia Cultural Studies Institutions. He serves on the Editorial Board of Cultural Studies and Advisory Board for Inter-Asia Cultural Studies, Router: A Journal of Cultural Studies, Communication and Society, and Localities. He is a founding core member of the Scholars’ Alliance for Academic Freedom.
 
 
    

About Us

Subscribe

Notes for contributors

Vol 21.1

21.1 visual essay

Vol 1-10

Vol 11-15

Vol 16-19

Vol 20.1

Vol 20.2

20.3

Vol 10-15 visual essay

Vol 16-19 visual essay

20.1 visual essay

20.2 visual essay

20.3 visual essay

IACS Society

Consortium of IACS Institutions

Related Publications

IACS Conferences

visual essay 20.2

A Chronology

About Us

Subscribe

Notes for contributors

Vol 21.1

21.1 visual essay

Vol 1-10

Vol 11-15

Vol 16-19

Vol 20.1

Vol 20.2

20.3

Vol 10-15 visual essay

Vol 16-19 visual essay

20.1 visual essay

20.2 visual essay

20.3 visual essay

IACS Society

Consortium of IACS Institutions

Related Publications

IACS Conferences

visual essay 20.2

A Chronology